Luscious Lemon Slices

Move over, Nigella, I’ve already declared my new baking goddess to be our own Aussie Belinda Jeffery, and in trying yet another recipe from this book, she hasn’t let me down!

I’ve explained before that my sister is a lemon/citrus freak, and absolutely adores my lemon tart. While I enjoy making it for her, the overnight resting and general fiddliness of the recipe means that I don’t make it for her very often, so I have been on the lookout for something which would pack a puckery lemon punch without the prep time. When I saw these golden lemon slices, topped with waxy jade pistachio pieces in Belinda Jeffery’s “Mix & Bake“, I knew that I had to give them a go. And since my sister is currently stressing in the throes of exam preparations, what better way to bring her some comfort than with a tasty treat?

I didn’t have the correct size tin for baking these, but no matter, they still turned out marvellously! Delicious shortbread-like base topped by meltingly soft slightly puckery lemon, with a thin layer of meringue crowned by pistachios.

If you’re a lemon slice fan, I guarantee these will rock your casbah if you give ’em a shot ๐Ÿ˜‰

Luscious Lemon Slice
(From “Mix & Bake” by Belinda Jeffery)

Base Ingredients
225g all-purpose flour
80g pure icing sugar, sifted
180g cold unsalted butter
Finely grated zest of 1 unwaxed lemon
1/2 tsp vanilla extract
2 tsp iced water

Lemon Topping Ingredients
6 large eggs
600g caster sugar
Finely grated zest of 3 unwaxed lemons
250mL freshly squeezed lemon juice, strained
1/2 cup all-purpose flour

Icing sugar, chopped pistachios or fresh berries and cream to serve


Much of the fruit sold in supermarkets tends to have waxed skins, particularly citrus, so you should be careful to source your citrus from organic supermarkets or friendly neighbours/workmates whenever possible, especially if a recipe calls for the use of zest. Alternatively, if you can’t get your hands on unwaxed citrus, try using natural citrus extract.

1. Preheat your oven to 180 degrees C and butter then line a 32 x 24 x 5cm baking tin with non-stick baking paper (the paper makes removal of the delicate slice easy, and the butter helps the paper to stay in place till it’s ready to be baked).

2. To make the base: put the flour, icing sugar and lemon zest in a food processor and pulse. Add the butter and pulse till mixture resembles coarse breadcrumbs, then add the vanilla extract and iced water till the pastry forms a ball. Remove from the processor and press evenly into the lined tin, making sure to get it into the corners.

3. Bake the base for about 15-20 minutes, or till the edges have gone golden and the pastry has dried a fair bit and firmed up.

4. While the pastry is baking, use a balloon whisk to lightly beat together the eggs, sugar, lemon zest and juice. Sift the flour over the top and whisk it in till the mixture is smooth.

5. Once the base is cooked, remove from the oven and set aside for about 5-10 minutes to cool and drop the oven temperature to 150 degrees C (the warmer the pastry, the more apt it will be to absorb the egg mixture and go cakey and soggy). Once the base has sufficiently cooled, briefly whisk the egg mixture and pour over the base.

6. Carefully return to the oven and bake for 35-45 minutes, or till the topping has set. Once baked, remove from the oven and cool on a wire rack.

If serving immediately, slice using a knife with a hot blade (stand in a glass of bowling water then dry), dust with a light sprinkling of icing sugar and top with chopped pistachios or fresh berries and cream.

If not serving straight away, cover tin tightly with cling film and keep in the fridge for 3-4 days. Bring back to room temperature before serving, and decorate with icing sugar and nuts or berries.

Make sure the slice has sufficiently cooled before slicing up, and clean between slices if you don’t want raggedy pieces like mine!

[tags]Belinda Jeffery, citrus, lemon slice, pistachio, crochet, amigurumi[/tags]

For those who requested photos of what I’ve been making – here are two of my most recent creations and one work in progress! The teddy heads are mobile/cell phone danglies, the pink is made with a DK 3ply yarn and 3mm hook, the blue is made with a baby 4ply yarn and a 2.5mm hook. The red heart is being made with a 5ply crochet cotton and a 2.5mm hook :) What can I say? I like making cute miniature things!


  1. Thankyou – had this at a party yesterday & just had to know the recipe.

  2. My pleasure :)

  3. These look yummy – Pistachios are an interesting addition. I recently made some Lemon Bars, the results of which can be viewed here:
    I am also a Lemon fan, so I think I may have to try out some of your other lemon recipes featured on here. Love the photograhy too btw ๐Ÿ˜€

  4. I’ve just burnt my tongue on my first piece of this but it was worth it!
    Pretty easy to make and it tastes great even though I had to make up the half a cup of juice with limes and a tangelo.
    Will defiantly be making this again!

  5. @Melissa – Thanks for the lovely comment :)

    @Amy – Thanks for the lovely comment, I’m so glad you tried the recipe and that you enjoyed it! :)

  6. I baked the lemon slice yesterday, can’t work out what I did wrong but the lemon topping didn’t set within the time frame of the recipe, it took over an hour. I left the slice in the tin to cool & when I sliced it the topping had gone right through the base, it was sticky & hard to cut…. however, it did taste yummy!

    • Penny, I must say that it sounds like your oven temperature is off. Have you tried testing it to make sure that the oven’s thermostat is correct?

  7. with the recent abundance supply of lemon from the friends and colleagues, I finally got down to baking these and they were by far the best lemon slice. Baked it in a 9″x9″ cake tin and there were plenty to go around. Thanks for sharing.

  8. Hi,
    I think someone had the same problem as me but I have cooked this twice now and both times has happened.
    All the lemon topping has gone underneath the base so there is a biscuit layer on top then the baking paper then the lemon!
    I’m not sure what I’ve done wrong. Is it because I have gaps in baking paper? I also didn’t have a tin and used a glass pyrex dish similar size?
    It still tastes great but had to get it out take off paper then scoop lemon and smear it back on!

    • Hi Kimberley,

      I’m a bit perplexed by this. So long as you are making sure to press the base down firmly so there are no gaps and prebaking it, it should *not* be physically possible for the lemon topping to sink through. You can see how compacted the base is meant to be in the photos I’ve posted, please make sure you are following the instructions.

      • The base is absorbed by the egg mixture and goes to the bottom if your pastry was too wet when first made I think as same thing happened to me the second time I made it. You sometimes have adjust the amount of water, depending on how correctly you measured the flour, air temperature or humidity.

  9. I absolutely love this recipe!!!! Thank you so much!!!

  10. tingting says:

    Will using 6 eggs for the topping make it taste eggy at all? ๐Ÿ˜ฏ

  11. jillinks says:

    Is 600gm of sugar really necessary,,, or is it a mis print… Lovely recipe but I have no insulin left in the bank

    Might try 60gm next time


  12. Lezanne
    Twitter: lepetitfoursa

    These look and sound delicious – am definitely going to give them a try! Love your photography too.

  13. Tony
    Twitter: tonybakes

    Magnificent, this will be my project for the weekend. I’ll report back.

  14. Same thing happened to me re. topping soaking in and under the base. Left it to cool till barely luke warm to try and avoid the problem but the topping was just so runny that I think it was bound to happen. Havent tried it yet but Im sure it will still taste good :)
    Also cut the sugar to 500g, 600g just seemed too extreme and I like things tart and NZ lemons are already pretty sweet.

  15. Tony
    Twitter: tonybakes


    I’m a beginner with baking but had to make this recipe – here’s how mine turned out.
    Tony recently posted..Luscious Lemon Slice

  16. And this is what I’m making for my Mum! via @kitchenwench

Speak Your Mind


CommentLuv badge

Blog Widget by LinkWithin
%d bloggers like this: